Portuguese Phrase
De qual arranha-céu você está falando?
Meaning
This phrase is used to ask for clarification about a specific skyscraper when multiple have been mentioned or implied. It literally translates to "Of which skyscraper are you talking?". The preposition "de" (of/from) is required because the verb "falar" (to talk) often takes "de" when referring to the topic of conversation.
When to use
You would use this phrase when someone mentions a skyscraper, but it's unclear which one they mean, perhaps in a conversation about city architecture, real estate, or a news story. It's a direct and polite way to seek clarification.
✦Grammar Breakdown
Dequalarranha-céuvocêestáfalando
De
This is a preposition meaning "of" or "from". Here, it's required by the verb "falar" when referring to the topic of conversation. "Falar de algo" means "to talk about something."
Qual
This is an interrogative pronoun meaning "which" or "what". It's used when choosing from a specific set or identifying something, and it agrees in number (singular/plural) but not gender.
Arranha-céu
This is a compound noun meaning "skyscraper" (literally "sky-scraper"). It is masculine and singular in this context, and its plural form is "arranha-céus".
Você
This is a second-person singular pronoun, meaning "you". It's widely used in Brazil for both formal and informal contexts, making it a versatile choice for addressing someone.
Está
This is the conjugation of the verb "estar" (to be) in the third-person singular present tense. It's used for temporary states, locations, or to form continuous tenses like the present continuous.
Falando
This is the gerund of the verb "falar" (to talk). When combined with "estar" (e.g., "está falando"), it forms the present continuous tense, indicating an ongoing action.
🗨In Conversation
Aquele arranha-céu é impressionante!
That skyscraper is impressive!
De qual arranha-céu você está falando?
Which skyscraper are you talking about?
✕Common Mistakes
Que arranha-céu você está falando?
"Que" is generally used for "what" or "which" when there's an open-ended choice or definition. "Qual" is used when choosing from a specific set or when asking for identification. Here, you're identifying which one from a potential group.
Qual arranha-céu você está falando?
The verb "falar" (to talk) requires the preposition "de" (about/of) when referring to the topic of conversation. So, "falar de algo" means "to talk about something."
↔Alternatives
Qual arranha-céu?
Which skyscraper?
Sobre qual arranha-céu você está falando?
About which skyscraper are you talking?
Você pode especificar qual arranha-céu?
Can you specify which skyscraper?
Cultural Tip
In Portuguese, especially Brazilian Portuguese, the use of "você" is very common and generally considered polite in most everyday situations. The construction "de qual" is crucial here; omitting "de" or using "que" instead of "qual" would sound unnatural or incorrect. Brazilians are generally quite direct in their questions, and this phrase fits well into typical conversational patterns.

